It’s one thing opening a new pub, but once the furore has died down, keeping the hype going is quite another. But that’s exactly what co-owners and best mates Mike Dove and Tommy Higgs have achieved since reopening the doors of one of Witney’s favourite pubs in 2023.

Keeping their feet firmly on the ground, the duo want to ensure that The ‘Shoes remains a local, neighbourhood pub where there’s always a friendly face, excellent service, a laid back vibe, packed events programme and some great pub food.

James at The Three Horseshoes

With Witney’s food offering really taking off, there’s now more skin in the game, not that The Three Horseshoes seems to be suffering – Christmas bookings ramping up (the turkey and all the trimmings is £20).

But we still wanted to check out new chef Ryan Priddey and see how he’s keeping it real, while making his mark, especially as Ryan was shortlisted from thousands of nominees for Essential Cuisine’s Pub Chef Of The Year 2026 back in April and took part in a live cook off at The Excel Arena, coming third.

Three Horseshoes

The specials menu was a good place to start. How about buttermilk fried local pheasant goujons with pheasant gravy (£10)? Or the 48 hour short rib of Oxfordshire beef with white onion puree, miso braised cabbage, smoke onion squash and beef sauce (£28) to whet the appetite?

pheasant goujons

We dived in, the pheasant goujons moist inside with a crunchy exterior, great for dunking in the gravy. We also tried the chips and curry sauce – the sauce coconut milk based, the Asian twist a surprising take on a chippy classic.

miso burger at The Three Horseshoes

The miso mushroom burger with spicy mayo, pickled kohlrabi and fries (£16.50) was another unexpected offering, and a testament to how Ryan is switching things up, no lazy vegetarian pickings here, but instead a tasty, flavoured, interesting take on a burger infused with juicy, dark Chinese flavours, enhanced with pickles, and a hint of heat.

chicken at The Three Horseshoes

The half Cotswold chicken with chips and garlic butter (£18.50) was nicely cooked, the top smothered in herbs, a hugely generous portion, although aesthetically it looked a bit odd on the plate, an island in a sea of chips.

As for the 48 hour short rib of Oxfordshire beef with white onion puree, miso braised cabbage, smoke onion squash and beef sauce, it was a labour of love – the gravy rich, the veg nicely braised, the meat tender, all packed full of flavour.

48 hour short rib at The Three Horseshoes

A craving for fromage to accompany the lovely wine was assuaged by the Horseshoes’ cheese selection served with crackers and chutney (£10), the plate unadorned.

And oh ,the sticky toffee pudding with salted caramel sauce and clotted cream (£8), so rich and spongy and almost bitter, lifted by the sweet caramel sauce and the thick cream. I can still taste it now.

sticky toffee pudding at The Three Horseshoes

If we have any criticisms it’s that the chips were a bit ordinaire and the presentation needs a tweak, but having nabbed the last remaining table, the place was still heaving when we left, the bar, and dining area packed with couples, friends and families chatting away and tucking in to Ryan’s food. It looks like The ‘Shoes is still ticking all the boxes.

The Three Horseshoes is at 78 Corn St, Witney OX28 6BS. https://www.threehorseshoeswitney.co.uk